Yes, more humans-vs-robots

The wave of commentary about the relative utility of humans versus robots in space exploration has made its way to the nation’s largest newspapers. Monday’s Boston Globe takes a fairly subtle approach, praising Stardust and New Horizons while mentioning only in passing that such missions demonstrate “the scientific value of robotic projects that do not […]

State space policy in Florida and New Mexico

Florida governor Jeb Bush yesterday unveiled a request for $55 million in state space spending to go along with recommendations of a commission examining the future role of the state in the space industry. $35 million would go to renovating buildings at Cape Canaveral to support CEV operations, in a bid to lure CEV work […]

More humans-vs-robots

Apparently the confluence of the return of Stardust and the impending launch of New Horizons touched a few more nerves than just the Des Moines Register, as noted here yesterday. The Seattle Times compares the risks and benefits of human and robotic spaceflight:

Opportunities and dangerous initiatives beyond human limits reinforce concerns about sending human […]

Another humans-vs-robots salvo

Amid all the congratulatory news about the successful return Sunday of NASA’s Stardust spacecraft, is shouldn’t be that surprising that someone has tried to use the mission to make a point about space policy. An editorial in Tuesday’s Des Moines Register takes note that Stardust was a robotic mission:

Best of all, the stardust was […]

More on Triana

In Sunday’s New York Times featured an op-ed by Robert Park bemoaning NASA’s decision to terminate the Triana mission. (See previous discussion of that decision.) Park argues that the ties the mission had to then-Vice President Al Gore doomed the mission:

Scientists had dreamed of such an observatory for years. They hoped Mr. Gore’s influence […]

Entrepreneurial space transportation industry consensus statement

What role can—and should—the US government play in supporting the development of low-cost, responsive space transportation? That is the question tackled in a one-page statement released today that represents the consensus of over two dozen companies and organizations in the industry. The genesis of this document was a one-day meeting held at the request of […]

Pluto and plutonium

I noted here last month that there has been very little controversy surrounding the pending launch of NASA’s New Horizons mission, a spacecraft powered by an RTG. That has changed a little bit, but not significantly, in the last couple of weeks. The most notable development was a protest outside the gates of Cape Canaveral […]

Playing the China card

A group of Congressmen visiting China report that China has raised the possibility of cooperating with the US in space. According to the AP and Reuters, Chinese officials meeting with the Congressional delegation discussed a proposal to re-engineer the docking system on China’s Shenzhou spacecraft so it is compatible with the ISS and other US […]

And you thought being an astronaut was tough

Try campaigning for Parliament in Canada! That’s what Marc Garneau, the first Canadian in space, is discovering as, among other things, he spends cold mornings greeting train riders (en français) at a station in his riding west of Montreal, the Montreal Gazette reports. The campaign has been a little rough for the first-time candidate (and […]

Export control and launch vehicles

A couple articles of note from Monday’s issue of The Space Review: Grant Bonin completes his examination of the use of medium-lift vehicles instead of a heavy-lift launcher to carry out the Vision for Space Exploration. Part two looks at cost and reliability issues associated with large versus smaller vehicles. Also, Ryan Zelnio offers a […]